MLB Addresses Controversial Ninth-Inning Call in Padres-Cubs Game

Wed, 29 Apr 2026 05:39:00 +0200

Major League Baseball addressed a disputed call during Monday night’s game between the San Diego Padres and Chicago Cubs, where a ball hit by Cubs infielder Matt Shaw down the third base line appeared to land in foul territory, though umpire Dan Merzel called it fair. Padres third baseman Ty France and fans at Petco Park believed the ball was foul. MLB cited its Umpire Manual, which states that a ball must be 'in contact' with fair territory to be considered fair, suggesting the call may not have fully aligned with league rules. While the league stopped short of declaring a definitive error, the explanation implied that the on-field ruling might have been incorrect. Despite the controversy, Padres closer Mason Miller, who had been dominant throughout the season, held on to secure a 9-7 win. Miller, reacting briefly to the incident, emphasized the team’s victory as the main focus. The discussion highlights ongoing challenges in officiating, especially in close plays where camera angles